Meridian, home

Research / MER/26/D23

Research Paper

A Deferred Decarbonisation Vote: The IMO Net-Zero Framework before December

MER/26/D23 · Meridian Research Team ·

A Deferred Decarbonisation Vote: The IMO Net-Zero Framework before December

The International Maritime Organization's draft Net-Zero Framework, approved in substance by the Marine Environment Protection Committee in April 2025 as amendments to MARPOL Annex VI, was not adopted in 2025. An extraordinary session adjourned for a year to seek broader consensus. Through 2026, intersessional working groups and MEPC 84 rebuilt a pathway toward a resumed adoption attempt: MEPC 85 is scheduled for 30 November to 3 December 2026, with the adjourned extraordinary session due to resume on 4 December subject to MEPC 85's confirmation. This paper reads the official IMO updates to Parties to the UNFCCC and the Organization's own meeting records, separates technical guideline progress from political adoption, and sets tests for December that do not mistake a procedural revival for an in-force fuel standard.

Key findings and scope

  • MEPC 83 approved draft MARPOL Annex VI amendments on the IMO Net-Zero Framework with a view to adoption at the second extraordinary session (MEPC/ES.2). That extraordinary session adjourned for one year to forge broader consensus and address Member State concerns [1, paragraphs 1-2].
  • MEPC 84 (27 April-1 May 2026) committed to rebuild consensus, established further intersessional work, and looked toward MEPC 85 (30 November-3 December 2026) and a resumed extraordinary session on 4 December 2026, subject to confirmation by MEPC 85 [2; 1, paragraphs 7-9].
  • ISWG-GHG 22 (1-4 September 2026) recorded nearly 1,200 registered participants and invited continued consultations to submit concrete proposals reflecting enhanced convergence for timely adoption and effective implementation [3].
  • The draft framework's implementing workstreams include greenhouse gas fuel intensity (GFI) calculation and verification, a GFI registry concept, rewards for zero or near-zero GHG fuels and technologies, and a proposed Net-Zero Fund/Facility. These workstreams proceed subject to, and without prejudice to, adoption of the amendments [1, paragraphs 3-6, 10].
  • As of 6 November 2026 the adoption vote has not occurred. No entry-into-force date can be stated as fact. Claims about automatic spring 2028 entry into force after a positive December vote are scenario statements used in secondary commentary; Meridian does not treat them as IMO decisions already taken.

This paper relies on IMO's submission to SBSTA 65 (Antalya, 9-14 November 2026), the Organization's MEPC 84 press briefing, and the ISWG-GHG 22 meeting summary. It does not forecast the December vote. It does not equate shipping-emissions governance with energy-chokepoint security analysis.

1. Why the Net-Zero Framework matters institutionally

International shipping emissions are addressed at IMO rather than through ordinary Kyoto/Paris Party inventories for domestic sectors. The 2023 IMO Strategy on Reduction of GHG Emissions from Ships sets the Organization's reduction ambition; mid-term measures are the regulatory bridge from strategy to ship-level obligations [1; 4]. The Net-Zero Framework is the draft legal vehicle for those mid-term measures inside MARPOL Annex VI: a global fuel-intensity approach coupled with economic elements, including debate over a fund or facility [1; 2].

If adopted, amendments to MARPOL Annex VI would bind Parties to that Annex under the Convention's amendment procedures. If not adopted, the Organization would still have technical guidelines under development, a political strategy document, and a credibility problem relative to its own timelines. The December meetings are therefore about whether the mid-term measure becomes law-in-waiting or remains a contested draft.

IMO Net-Zero path: milestone yearsMEPC 83 approval2025ES.2 adjournment2025MEPC 84 pathway2026MEPC 85 / resumed ES window2026
Figure 1. Calendar-year markers for key Net-Zero Framework milestones described in IMO’s SBSTA 65 note and MEPC 84 briefing. Values are years, not magnitudes of ambition. The December 2026 adoption outcome is not plotted because it had not occurred at the time of writing. Source: IMO SBSTA 65 note [1]; IMO MEPC 84 press briefing [2]. Chart drawn by Meridian.

2. The year of adjournment: what was paused, what continued

IMO's note to SBSTA 65 states that MEPC/ES.2, convened to adopt the draft amendments, agreed to adjourn for one year to forge broader consensus, reconcile differences and respond to concerns, including through adjustments and supporting measures [1, paragraph 2]. Adjournment was not abandonment. ISWG-GHG 20 and 21, held after the extraordinary session and before MEPC 84, continued work on implementing provisions without prejudice to adoption, including draft GFI calculation guidelines, verification-related draft amendments, wind-propulsion energy guidance, discussion of rewards for zero or near-zero GHG emission technologies and fuels, possible governing provisions for revenue disbursement through a proposed Net-Zero Fund, and early work on a GFI Registry's functional requirements [1, paragraphs 3-6].

That split is analytically crucial. Technical elaboration can reduce uncertainty and build confidence. It can also create the appearance of inevitability while the political objection that forced adjournment remains unresolved. MEPC 84's task was to choose a path that kept adoption possible in 2026 without pretending consensus already existed.

3. MEPC 84: "back on track" as a political claim

IMO's 1 May 2026 press briefing reports that MEPC 84 concluded with a commitment to rebuild consensus on global shipping emissions. Nearly 100 delegations took the floor on adoption of mid-term measures. The Committee agreed to establish an intersessional Working Group pathway, allow submission of new amendments and adjustments to the previously approved draft, schedule intersessional meetings on 1-4 September and 23-27 November ahead of MEPC 85 (30 November-3 December), and hold a one-day expert workshop on chain-of-custody models for fuels. The adjourned extraordinary session is scheduled to resume on 4 December 2026, subject to discussions at MEPC 85 [2].

Secretary-General Arsenio Dominguez's "back on track" formulation, quoted in the same briefing, is a leadership assessment, not a vote count [2]. Meridian treats it as evidence of institutional intent to recover a timeline. The substantive disagreements that caused adjournment are not itemised exhaustively in the public briefing. The SBSTA note records that some delegations at MEPC 84 called for adoption of the draft in its current form with concerns handled through guidelines, while others suggested amending the draft or considering alternatives [1, paragraph 8]. That bifurcation remains the political structure of the problem.

Table 1. Decision points from approval to the December 2026 window

Date / session Status of the Net-Zero Framework Source
MEPC 83 (April 2025) Draft MARPOL Annex VI amendments approved with a view to adoption [1]
MEPC/ES.2 (October 2025) Adoption session adjourned for one year [1]
ISWG-GHG 20-21 (post-ES.2 / pre-MEPC 84) Implementing guidelines advanced without prejudice to adoption [1]
MEPC 84 (27 April-1 May 2026) Path set toward MEPC 85 and possible resumed ES on 4 Dec 2026 [1]; [2]
ISWG-GHG 22 (1-4 Sept 2026) Further convergence work; ~1,200 registered participants [3]
ISWG-GHG 23 (23-27 Nov 2026, scheduled) Further pre-MEPC 85 consultations (as scheduled at MEPC 84) [2]; [1]
MEPC 85 (30 Nov-3 Dec 2026) Consider outcomes; confirm whether ES resumes [1]; [2]
Resumed MEPC/ES.2 (4 Dec 2026, subject to confirmation) Possible adoption vote on amendments [1]; [2]

n/a: outcome of December 2026 sessions (not yet occurred at the time of writing).

4. What the draft architecture contains (without prejudging adoption)

Public IMO updates describe a basket of mid-term measures built around greenhouse gas fuel intensity requirements for ships, compliance approaches, and economic elements including a proposed Fund/Facility and rewards for zero or near-zero GHG fuels and energy sources [1, paragraphs 10-11]. A centralised GFI Registry is envisaged as a data platform, with attention to interoperability with the existing IMO Data Collection System, cyber security, data governance and geographical inclusivity [1, paragraph 6]. Chain-of-custody workshop planning shows that fuel certification and emissions attribution across supply chains are recognised operational bottlenecks [2].

None of these elements is trivial. A fuel-intensity standard without workable verification would be gamed. A fund without agreed disbursement rules would not address equity concerns that contributed to delay. Rewards without a methodology would be political slogans. The 2026 intersessional work is therefore necessary whether one favours adoption of the April 2025 text or a modified text. Necessity is not sufficiency: guidelines cannot substitute for the amendment decision itself.

5. Equity, development and the politics inside "concerns"

The public record opened for this paper does not reduce Member State concerns to a single slogan. Patterns visible in IMO's own summaries include calls to adopt now and fix details later, calls to reopen text, and attention to supporting measures, rewards, fund governance and technical feasibility [1; 2; 3]. Developing-State participation support appears through the Voluntary Multi-Donor Trust Fund referenced for ISWG-GHG 23 and MEPC 85 attendance [1, paragraph 67 area]. Process inclusion is not the same as substantive satisfaction with economic outcomes of a global fuel standard.

Meridian's assessment is that December will turn on whether enough States that blocked or doubted adoption in 2025 see either textual adjustment or implementing packages as adequate, and whether States that want immediate adoption accept enough modification to keep a coalition. That is a consensus-building problem under IMO amendment culture, not a simple majoritarian climate negotiation transplanted from UNFCCC.

6. Strongest objections

Objection 1: adjournment already killed credibility

Critics argue that failing to adopt in 2025 showed IMO cannot regulate in time, pushing regional measures to dominate. The objection has force on urgency. It understates the Organization's continuing technical work and the formal scheduling of a 2026 adoption window [1; 2]. Credibility will be determined by whether that window produces a decision, not by whether adjournment was uncomfortable.

Objection 2: a global measure will punish developing fleets

A second objection holds that fuel-intensity rules and economic measures will raise costs for States and operators with less access to zero or near-zero fuels. The framework debates on rewards, fund disbursement and supporting measures exist largely because of this objection [1]. Whether the final package adequately answers it cannot be known before the text put to a vote is fixed. Dismissing the equity concern as obstruction ignores a central reason ES.2 adjourned.

Objection 3: endless guidelines are a delay tactic

Conversely, some pro-adoption voices see implementing-guideline proliferation as a method to postpone the hard vote. ISWG-GHG 22's call for concrete proposals reflecting enhanced convergence suggests the Chair is trying to force text toward decision rather than infinite workshopping [3]. The test is whether November's ISWG-GHG 23 and MEPC 85 present a voteable package rather than another workplan.

Objection 4: shipping is a small share of global emissions, so the fight is disproportionate

Even if international shipping is a minority of global GHG emissions, it is a large share of transport emissions and of emissions not easily covered by national NDCs. IMO's SBSTA note exists precisely because the UNFCCC process tracks this sectoral regulatory track [1]. Proportionality arguments do not erase the institutional fact that IMO is the agreed specialised forum.

6A. MARPOL mechanics and why procedure is substance

Amendments to MARPOL Annex VI follow IMO's established amendment process. The political choice to seek adoption through an extraordinary session after MEPC 83 approval was meant to accelerate mid-term measures in line with the 2023 Strategy [1]. Adjournment converted that acceleration into a probation period. Resuming ES.2 on 4 December only if MEPC 85 confirms is a procedural fuse: it prevents an automatic vote theatre if MEPC 85 finds the text still unfit [1; 2]. Observers should therefore watch MEPC 85's confirmation decision as closely as the adoption vote itself. A failure to confirm resumption would be a second deferral by another name.

6B. Fuel intensity, registries and the compliance imagination

A greenhouse gas fuel-intensity standard needs numbers, boundaries and verification. ISWG work on GFI calculation, verification, wind-propulsion energy accounting and registry functions is the unglamorous core of enforceability [1, paragraphs 4-6]. Without those pieces, adoption would export chaos to administrations and recognised organisations. With those pieces but without adoption, the Organization will have built a machine with no statutory switch. That is the central irony of 2026: the better the guidelines become, the more visible the missing amendment becomes.

The proposed Net-Zero Fund/Facility and ZNZ rewards are the political core for many developing States and for operators facing fuel-price and technology-access risk [1]. December packages that mute these elements to secure a quick vote may win a procedural majority in the short term and lose implementation coalitions afterward. Packages that load every equity demand into unsettled fund governance may preserve fairness claims and lose the vote. The Chair's ISWG-GHG 22 observation of willingness to make further concrete progress is hopeful institutional language; it is not yet a reconciled text [3].

6C. Regional measures and the cost of further delay

European Commission commentary welcoming MEPC 84's outcome illustrates that major economies are watching IMO timelines while maintaining their own shipping-climate instruments [6]. Further IMO delay would not freeze regional regulation; it would likely intensify it. That prospect cuts two ways. It can pressure hold-outs toward a global measure. It can also fragment compliance for ships in multiple regimes, raising costs and weakening the claim that IMO remains the primary global forum. Meridian's strategic reading is that December is therefore about IMO's institutional centrality as much as about tonnes of CO2.

7. Observable tests for 30 November-4 December 2026

  1. Confirmation: Does MEPC 85 confirm resumption of the extraordinary session on 4 December?
  2. Text: Is the text put forward the April 2025 approved draft, a revised draft, or a bifurcated option set?
  3. Adoption: Are MARPOL Annex VI amendments adopted, rejected, or further deferred?
  4. Fund/rewards: If adopted or packaged politically, do Parties clarify Fund governance and ZNZ reward methodology enough for implementation planning?
  5. After-vote chronology: If adopted, what entry-into-force pathway does IMO communicate, without secondary media filling gaps?

7A. Shipping emissions governance is not energy-chokepoint analysis

Attacks on commercial shipping and marine pollution risks in the Strait of Hormuz were addressed in a separate MEPC 84 resolution track reported in the same press briefing that covered the Net-Zero Framework pathway [2]. Those security and pollution issues matter. They are not substitutes for the fuel-intensity amendment decision. This paper keeps them analytically distinct. A State can support navigational security measures and still oppose the current Net-Zero text, or the reverse. Bundling every maritime headline into one "shipping crisis" narrative obscures the specific legal question before MEPC 85 and the resumed extraordinary session.

7B. What a good December outcome would look like without predicting it

A durable outcome would combine: a clear yes-or-no on adoption; if yes, an intelligible compliance start pathway and enough Fund/rewards architecture to keep equity coalitions engaged; if no, an explicit diagnosis of remaining blockers and a short, bounded mandate rather than open-ended drift. Either yes or no can be responsible. Another silent adjournment without explanation would not be. ISWG-GHG 22's nearly 1,200 registered participants show that the issue commands attention across industry, governments and observers [3]. Attention increases the cost of vagueness.

7C. Evidence standard for claims made after December

Whatever happens in early December, analysts will face incentives to over-claim. An adoption vote is not immediate entry into force. Guideline finalisation, registry readiness, Fund capitalisation and first compliance years would still lie ahead [1]. A deferral is not proof that shipping decarbonisation has ended; regional measures and national fuel policies would continue. Meridian's rule for post-December updates, foreshadowed here, is to separate: (a) the legal act of adoption or non-adoption; (b) the communicated entry-into-force pathway; (c) the state of implementing guidelines; and (d) any quantified emissions effect, which will not be knowable from the vote week itself. Mixing those layers is how shipping-climate commentary becomes unreliable.

7D. Participation intensity as a signal, not a verdict

Nearly 1,200 registered participants at ISWG-GHG 22, and nearly 100 delegations taking the floor at MEPC 84 on mid-term measures, show unusual intensity for a technical shipping committee process [2; 3]. Intensity can signal impending compromise or impending rupture. It cannot be read mechanically as either. Combined with the formal scheduling of ISWG-GHG 23 immediately before MEPC 85, it does show that Member States are not treating December as a routine cleanup item [1; 2]. For a research institute, the correct stance before the vote is disciplined agnosticism about the result and disciplined specificity about the documents and dates that will constitute the result.

8. Conclusion

The Net-Zero Framework enters December 2026 as a recovered possibility rather than an achieved regulation. MEPC 84 and the 2026 intersessional cycle rebuilt a track after a costly adjournment. Technical scaffolding around fuel intensity, registries, rewards and a fund has thickened. Political consensus has been asserted as a goal, not demonstrated as a result. Shipping's decarbonisation governance will be judged by whether the Organization can convert that scaffolding into adopted MARPOL amendments - or explain, with precision, why it still cannot.

References

  1. International Maritime Organization, "Update on IMO's work to address GHG emissions from international shipping", note to UNFCCC SBSTA 65, Antalya, 9-14 November 2026, https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/OurWork/Environment/Documents/IMO%20submission%20to%20SBSTA%2065.pdf (accessed 6 November 2026).
  2. International Maritime Organization, "IMO progresses work on ship emissions, pollution and ocean protection" (MEPC 84 press briefing), 1 May 2026, https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/pressbriefings/pages/imo-progresses-work-on-ship-emissions-pollution-and-ocean-protection.aspx (accessed 6 November 2026).
  3. International Maritime Organization, "Intersessional Working Group on Reduction of GHG Emissions from Ships (ISWG-GHG 22), 1-4 September 2026", meeting summary, https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/meetingsummaries/pages/iswg-ghg-22.aspx (accessed 6 November 2026).
  4. International Maritime Organization, 2023 IMO Strategy on Reduction of GHG Emissions from Ships, information page, https://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Environment/Pages/2023-IMO-Strategy-on-Reduction-of-GHG-Emissions-from-Ships.aspx (accessed 6 November 2026).
  5. International Maritime Organization, Reducing greenhouse gas emissions from ships (hot topic / work page), https://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Environment/Pages/Reducing-greenhouse-gas-emissions-from-ships.aspx (accessed 6 November 2026).
  6. European Commission, "The Commission welcomes outcome of the IMO 84th Marine Environment Protection Committee", 4 May 2026, https://transport.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/commission-welcomes-outcome-imo-84th-marine-environment-protection-committee-2026-05-04_en (accessed 6 November 2026; used as supplementary confirmation of MEPC 84 timing, not as authority for IMO legal text).
  7. MARPOL Annex VI amendment pathway as described in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  8. MEPC 83 approval of draft Net-Zero Framework amendments, as described in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  9. MEPC/ES.2 adjournment decision, as described in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  10. ISWG-GHG 21 outcomes on GFI guidelines, ZNZ rewards and Fund provisions, as described in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  11. GFI Registry functional-requirements discussion, as described in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  12. IMO Data Collection System interoperability references in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  13. Chain-of-custody expert workshop planning in [2] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  14. Voluntary Multi-Donor Trust Fund participation support references in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  15. IMO multi-donor GHG Trust Fund (established 2019) reference in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  16. GESAMP-LCA working group reporting pathway to MEPC 85, as noted in [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  17. ISWG-GHG 23 scheduling (23-27 November 2026) as stated in [2] and [1] (accessed 6 November 2026).
  18. MEPC 85 dates (30 November-3 December 2026) as stated in [1] and [2] (accessed 6 November 2026).